What Influence by Robert Cialdini Teaches Us About Cold Emailing

Cold emailing can often feel like sending messages into a void, with responses as elusive as ever. But what if you could approach cold emails not as sales pitches but as opportunities to influence? Robert Cialdini’s book, Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion, offers timeless insights into how people make decisions and what drives them to take action. His principles of influence can transform your approach to cold emailing, helping to create connections and drive engagement.

Let’s explore how these principles translate directly into cold email strategies, providing a framework to elevate your outreach efforts.

1. Reciprocity: Give Before You Ask

Influence Insight: People feel obligated to return favors. In sales, creating a feeling of value upfront encourages engagement and sets a positive tone.

Cold Email Application: Begin by offering value before you make a request. Whether it’s sharing a resource, an article, a unique insight, or a short personalized video, start with something genuinely helpful. Instead of an immediate pitch, try starting with something like, “I thought you’d find this resource helpful…”

• Example: “Hi [Name], I noticed you’re working on [specific project/goal]. Here’s a [relevant resource or insight] that might save you time or offer a fresh perspective. If you’re interested in similar solutions, let me know—I’m happy to share more!”

By leading with value, you engage the reciprocity principle and increase the likelihood of a response.

2. Commitment and Consistency: Small Steps Lead to Bigger Commitments

Influence Insight: People strive to act in ways that align with their previous commitments. Small agreements can pave the way for larger ones.

Cold Email Application: Instead of going for the hard sell, ask for a smaller action or commitment. This could be as simple as responding to a question, reading a short article, or watching a quick demo.

• Example: “Would you be open to a 2-minute video that explains how we help teams like yours improve their onboarding process?”

Starting small makes it easier for recipients to engage without feeling overwhelmed. Once they’ve taken that initial step, they’re more likely to continue engaging with you.

3. Social Proof: Leverage Success Stories

Influence Insight: People are influenced by the actions and endorsements of others, especially when they’re uncertain.

Cold Email Application: Incorporate relevant testimonials, case studies, or references to well-known clients or industry names. Mentioning a recognizable company that uses your product can create immediate credibility.

• Example: “Companies like [Notable Brand 1] and [Notable Brand 2] have improved their customer response times by 30% with our platform. Do you think this could help [Recipient’s Company] as well?”

Social proof helps reassure recipients that your offering is not only legitimate but is trusted by others in their space.

4. Liking: Make It Personal and Relatable

Influence Insight: People are more likely to say “yes” to those they feel a connection with. Liking can come from similarity, compliments, or showing genuine interest.

Cold Email Application: Avoid generic, impersonal messages. Research your prospect and include details that show you’ve taken the time to understand their background, interests, or pain points. A quick line about a shared interest or mutual connection makes the email feel personal and genuine.

• Example: “Hi [Name], I saw your recent LinkedIn post about [specific topic]. It really resonated with me because we’re seeing similar challenges with our clients who are also navigating this shift. I thought I’d reach out to share some approaches that have worked well for us in addressing [related challenge]—would you be open to a quick chat?”

Why It Works: This version feels more personal because it shows you’ve not only read something relevant to them but also relate to it yourself. You’re framing your outreach as a conversation based on shared experiences rather than a one-sided pitch.

5. Authority: Establish Your Credibility

Influence Insight: People respect authority and are more inclined to follow suggestions from experts.

Cold Email Application: Highlight your credibility subtly by mentioning relevant experience, client successes, or industry expertise. Authority can be established without boasting—sometimes linking to a resource on your website or mentioning a published article can communicate expertise effectively.

• Example: “We’ve worked with several leading [industry] companies, focusing on [specific result or transformation]. I’d be happy to share more if it aligns with your current priorities.”

By positioning yourself as a knowledgeable resource, you subtly increase the likelihood of a positive response.

6. Scarcity: Create a Sense of Urgency

Influence Insight: People are motivated to act when they fear losing out on something limited or exclusive.

Cold Email Application: Use scarcity wisely in cold emails. Mention limited slots for consultations, exclusive content, or upcoming deadlines. However, it’s crucial to ensure that any scarcity is genuine, as false urgency can erode trust.

• Example: “I have a few remaining slots for early access to our beta testing program next month. Would you be interested in reserving a spot?”

This tactic works best toward the end of the email, once you’ve established the value of what’s on offer.

7. Unity: Build a Sense of Belonging

Influence Insight: Unity, or shared identity, increases persuasion. When people feel connected by shared goals, values, or experiences, they’re more receptive to influence.

Cold Email Application: Establish a shared purpose with the prospect, whether it’s a common industry goal, a similar challenge, or a shared mission.

• Example: “Hi [Name], I work with leaders in [their industry] who are passionate about [industry goal, e.g., improving sustainability in tech]. Together, we’ve been exploring innovative ways to make this a reality. Would you be interested in connecting to exchange insights and discuss what’s working for similar teams facing the same challenges?”

Why It Works: This approach taps into a shared mission, emphasizing that the recipient isn’t alone in their challenges and goals. You’re aligning with them as part of a collective journey rather than as an outsider looking to sell something.

Training Your AI SDR Tool with Cialdini’s Principles

Today, many companies use AI tools like ChatGPT to handle parts of their cold outreach. To maximize these tools, you can feed Cialdini’s principles as specific instructions. Here’s how to use each principle as a theme, A/B testing variations until you find the best-performing approach:

1. Reciprocity: Instruct the AI to start emails by sharing a helpful resource or tip.
2. Commitment: Program the AI to make small asks, like viewing a short video, instead of asking for full meetings.
3. Social Proof: Add instructions to reference well-known clients or success stories relevant to the recipient’s industry.
4. Liking: Have the AI reference personalized details, like shared interests or a recent post, to make emails more relatable.
5. Authority: Include authority-building elements like industry insights, links to credible resources, or subtle mentions of expertise.
6. Scarcity: Set the AI to mention exclusivity or limited availability, provided it’s authentic.
7. Unity: Guide the AI to speak about shared goals or common challenges to build a sense of belonging.

By setting up these principles as themes and running A/B tests, you can determine what resonates best with your audience and then scale what works. This approach ensures that your AI SDR tool remains effective and feels more human in its outreach.

Conclusion: Crafting Cold Emails with Influence in Mind

By weaving Cialdini’s principles into your cold emails, you can make each interaction feel more personal, authentic, and persuasive. Here’s a quick recap:

1. Reciprocity: Offer value upfront.
2. Commitment and Consistency: Start with small requests.
3. Social Proof: Share relevant success stories.
4. Liking: Personalize and be relatable.
5. Authority: Establish subtle credibility.
6. Scarcity: Create urgency (genuinely).
7. Unity: Build a shared purpose.

Whether you’re crafting cold emails yourself or using an AI SDR tool, these principles allow you to build real connections that drive engagement. Remember, cold emails should feel like conversations rather than pitches, and a psychology-driven approach helps you achieve that.

If you’re ready to take your cold emails to the next level, try integrating these principles, A/B test each theme, and let the most successful approaches guide your strategy.

‍